Hey guys. Posting here has been helping me a lot lately so I thought to put this out. In play-testing and on forums I've been seeing the same comment geared towards the artwork for my game. It's not necessarily bad, I don't think, but it's caught my interest.
This link features all 16 character cards that would come with the base set. Download and or print this to see it at full resolution. Focus on the characters themselves.
https://docs.google.com/file/d/0ByWVLhRVj0ykVlFmUzBLQjRqN1E/edit
When I started working on the game seriously I made up a fantasy world where animal-folk lived in harmony with nature. If I'm being embarrassingly honest kids shows like Franklin, Little Bear, and games like Animal-Crossing inspired it. When I drew these characters a year ago I was thinking about making cartoon animals. Instead what people are seeing are "naked" animals. I mean, they are naked...but when I watched Franklin I never thought "man, Bear should put on a shirt."
Even looking back today the thought never came to mind. Little Bear was even weirder in that Little Bears parents were always fully clothed...yet he never was. Actually that's a lot weirder now but the point is I never thought about it before today! In both those shows the characters aren't drawn "cartoony" like Sonic characters. They looked like, to me, drawn animals. This won't necessarily make me throw out all the artwork and start from scratch but it has been bothering me.
TL;DR: What do these characters look like to you? Some people call them "naked animals" and are put off others call them "cartoon animals" and aren't bothered. Any comment / thoughtful advice would be appreciated.
Thanks, 3
Gah, I did it again...
This happens every time I update the doc. I forget to fix the sharing options too. It's good to go now!