I'm building a tile-laying game where scoring happens each round. This means you've got to keep a running total of your score (or record each score individually and tally up at the end). Must my game include a piece of paper and a mini-golf pencil for keeping score? [Read on for my thought process.]
I'll be publishing through thegamecrafter.com, so I bump the price (or take a hit to profit) for each extraneous component I add. If my game needed dices or minis, I'd never dream of saying "find those on your own, they aren't included". But a simple tally sheet and pencil seem like they can be left out, since everyone has SOMETHING they can record score with (pencil and paper, smart phone, tablet, etc.). Will this come across as extremely cheesy, or will gamers appreciate that I didn't needlessly add another $.50 of components they already possess in abundance?
Thanks Stormyknight! I got a pretty similar response over on TGC's game design forum - a few people (especially designers) don't think it's necessary, but most consumers/players expect the box to contain everything they need. I'm going to see if I can create something that fits my theme - a score track, counters, etc. - rather than a pencil + paper. But worst case, there'll be a pencil + paper :)