Agreed.
As a personal counter-opinion, here is a sampling of some of my favorite games which include auctions that work quite well:
Taj Mahal
Ra
El Grande
Homesteaders
Santiago
Princes of Florence
Tribune
I play a lot of Federation Commander (the easier version of Star Fleet Battles), and didn't even think of the auction mechanic in that game that we use quite often: the tractor auction.
If you have ever seen Star Trek you know one ship can drag another by using it "tractor" beam. In this game, if you try to grab another ship you announce you are activating the tractor and pay one energy. Now the opponent can apply negative tractor. If he bids one energy the tractor will not affect him, but then the first ship can bid another. This goes on until one side relents but both sides must pay what they ended up bidding, win or lose. Its a great way to get another ship to burn off power! And it works quite easily and well during play.
I get to play a scenario about once a week and really enjoy it. I think you can't appreciate a game until you have tried it a few times and gotten past the noob level. Larienna: maybe you should look for some new people to play with. Just sayin'.
Good Gaming groups are hard to find. I imagine that my group buy a lot of game and always want to play something new. So it get stuck with the "Cult of the new". I overheard somebody that he will manage to play his 6th game of twilight imperium 3. I know the game is long, but if you love a game, I think he would have had a chance to play more often. In general, I rarely play a game twice unless I own it. Even the games I bring are hard to hit the table because I need to compete against all the other games the people have brought. It's even worst to try playing a game I designed.
One of the problem is that they are overused.
As for Medici, that game was very annoying. One of my friend played with experienced people and it's even worst because people calculate how much they are going to gain to know the maximum price, so the game stall and takes a lot of time. Playing a game on a computer could be very boring, because it could calculate your max bid. It would be as boring as playing black jack and not taking any card when you have 17>. There would be almost no decision to take. So what makes the game work is the fact that most people cannot calculate the exact value of a hand ... but some will.
ABout medici
NO, it's not that complicated to program. You just calculate the payout of every player and then you could have something like this:
Player 1: max bid 15
Player 2: max bid 20
player 3: max bid 25
The max bid would be the value you gain from winning the items. So bidding more is actually a negative thing. (You lose money).
So If I am player 2, I know that the max bid I could push is 20, so I can easily outbid player 1, for force him to pay the maximum price, or hope he will miscalculate and make him lose money. I know that I cannot outbid player 3 but could try to raise the value to make him pay more (or gain less).
Once you have the value, it's boring because you know the optimal strategy. When you don't have the values, there is some risk to consider. That could have been interesting if there was some sort of hidden information that force you to estimate how much you could get without really knowing. But since everything is open, you can calculate the value of everything, so it's the player with the most brain power that wins.
NO, it's not that complicated to program. You just calculate the payout of every player and then you could have something like this:
Player 1: max bid 15
Player 2: max bid 20
player 3: max bid 25
The max bid would be the value you gain from winning the items. So bidding more is actually a negative thing. (You lose money).
So If I am player 2, I know that the max bid I could push is 20, so I can easily outbid player 1, for force him to pay the maximum price, or hope he will miscalculate and make him lose money. I know that I cannot outbid player 3 but could try to raise the value to make him pay more (or gain less).
Once you have the value, it's boring because you know the optimal strategy. When you don't have the values, there is some risk to consider. That could have been interesting if there was some sort of hidden information that force you to estimate how much you could get without really knowing. But since everything is open, you can calculate the value of everything, so it's the player with the most brain power that wins.
This is hardly the optimal strategy.
At the risk of derailing the thread into a discussion of Medici strategy, you fail to mention a very important rule that make this quite suboptimal strategy:
You only have five slots to fill in a round. No more. This means that you could spend just up to the "optimal" price for a set of goods, but it diminishes your ability to purchase goods later in the same round. In addition, your ability to participate in auctions is limited to auctions you can legally take on to your ship. Thus, by winning a 3-good auction, you have limited yourself to participating in 2-good and 1-good auctions for the remainder of the round. You are then not able to drive up the prices on goods for other players. Feel free to calculate the value of a lot for each player and bid up to your own value; be prepared to lose.
1) In real-world auction / bidding situations, the item being bid on almost invariably goes for more than it is worth, or the contract comes in at a less expensive price than it should truly cost to complete. (I've read psychological studies that support these assertions. No, I don't have links to them right now.)
2) An auction, like any other mechanic, is neither good nor evil. It's simply a tool that we have at our disposal. Like any mechanic, it can be used well or mis-applied; there are scenarios where it excels and others where it is inappropriate. An auction (or any other mechanic) will work best when it does a good job of metaphysically matching up with what it represents in your game world. If you're using an auction to represent a contest of wills (or expenditure of energy in starships, as described earlier), there's a strong metaphysical correlation; the auction should work well. If you're using an auction to represent shifting gears in a car, the two have very little metaphysical correlation; odds are good that it won't work well at all.
Summary: If it doesn't feel right, take a step back and ask yourself what the auction actually represents in your game-world. If what it represents could be represented better by a different game mechanic, consider swapping in a different mechanic or altering the structure of the game make an auction a better fit.
 | Board Game Blueprint - New Episode Every Wednesday (21) by The Game Crafter |
| Premium Bullet & Premium Toxic Waste Board Game Pieces at The Game Crafter (0) by The Game Crafter |
| Build your own [insert game genre here] (3) by larienna |
 | PoA — Major shift back closer to FCE (2) by questccg |
| What “Should” Be in an RPG Design Book (11) by lewpuls |
| Blank Poker Card Sale - 3 Cents Each! (0) by The Game Crafter |
| Blank Playing Cards - Bridge 57mm x 89mm UK (1) by questccg |
| Finally returned after all these years (1) by DyminoMonsters2004 |
| State of the let-off Union - November 2024 (0) by let-off studios |
| Shoppe: The Simulation of Guilds (1) by questccg |
| The fine line between a game and a simulation (22) by X3M |
| Only 24 hours left to bid on games for the Extra Life Charity Auction (0) by The Game Crafter |
| Songs of Conquest is now 60% off plus an additional discount for... (5) by questccg |
| Returned the reMarkable 2 and purchased the BOOX Go 10.3 (3) by questccg |
| Happy Halloween 2024 (0) by questccg |
| Epic Metal Monster Coins - Now on Kickstarter - Created by The Game Crafter (0) by The Game Crafter |
| DuelBotz: Sample New Card (12) by questccg |
| 2 levels for an unit (wargames) (6) by X3M |
| Dragon Spark Playthrough (0) by The Game Crafter |
| New Board Game Pieces - Premium Water Droplet & Premium Blood Droplet (0) by The Game Crafter |
| Designer with an 'almost' ready product (18) by questccg |
| Protospiel Madison - Only 17 Days Away! (0) by The Game Crafter |
| New Board Game Pieces - Premium Milk Bottle & Premium Beer Mug (0) by The Game Crafter |
| Testing chat GPT for mechanics searching (6) by larienna |
| Epic Metal Monster Coins - Coming soon to Kickstarter - Need your feedback! (2) by questccg |
IMHO the auction works very well in my game, it's just a-thematic (but there's no strong theme there yet, anyway). Sure, I can't use action in all my future games, that's why I'm looking for alternatives.
I'm quite surprised there is a gaming group like this. If I knew I could play a game only 3 times a year, I wouldn't bother to learn it. I love learning new good games, but I also love learning the strategy well, which is just impossible this way. There are people who spend their whole lives playing a single game (chess or go), well that's the other extreme. For me, a game where a newbie may beat an experienced player is trash (still, it may be fun, but it's nothing I'd try to design).