Some good discussion following the September challenge. Discussion is where it's at now. Our feedback is the only reward these designers get, so let's make it good.
| Game | Score | Discussion |
| Loco Crazy by gilamonster |
9 pts | Oct 21 |
| InciDental A Round Tuit |
8 pts | Oct 22 |
| Patient Reloaded by BoardGent |
7 pts | Oct 23 |
| Sorry Forest by andymorris |
6 pts | Oct 24 |
Good job gilamonster, congrats on coming first. I voted gold for your entry. I really like the use of dice as pawns. I think it makes the movement much more interesting the way you've setup the game. I think the pickup/deliver concept on the ludo board is a really good fit.
I'd be a bit concerned about how fiddly the movement might get as you have to shift your dice around plus several cubes. I think you could have a train piece where you set the dice and cubes to hold them. That way they would move as a unit.
Thanks for the complements and positive comments, Andy!
Your suggestion about train pieces is a very good one - because apart from the definite practical advantages, this would certainly improve the look of the game (imagine little model steam locomotives with open-topped drivers' compartments to hold the dice, and wagons of cubes behind)
I gave Sorry Forest a number two position after a lot of back-and-fourthing between this and incidental - it was too close to call for me. I eventually chose the latter more for its cleverness of interpretation, rather than because I'd prefer to play it. I particularly liked the ideas of a modular board and using resources for territory control.
I like the addition of a variable timer in reloaded. That is certainly a good fit. The robot theme is good, but overall it just felt like a refacing of the original game. I felt like there needs to be more happening with cards.
The title was great for incidental. I also really like the adaptation of don't touch don't metal to metal from grabbing to sliding. If I followed it correctly, I feel the sequence of everyone setting up the patient and then cleaning the patient, might get a bit tedious.
![Syndicate content](/misc/feed.png "Comments for \"[GDS] OCTOBER 2016 "A Classic Spin" - Critiques\""){kind=small}
 | What “Should” Be in an RPG Design Book (10) by questccg |
 | Shoppe: The Simulation of Guilds (0) by questccg |
| The fine line between a game and a simulation (22) by X3M |
| Only 24 hours left to bid on games for the Extra Life Charity Auction (0) by The Game Crafter |
| Songs of Conquest is now 60% off plus an additional discount for... (5) by questccg |
| Returned the reMarkable 2 and purchased the BOOX Go 10.3 (3) by questccg |
| Happy Halloween 2024 (0) by questccg |
| Epic Metal Monster Coins - Now on Kickstarter - Created by The Game Crafter (0) by The Game Crafter |
| DuelBotz: Sample New Card (12) by questccg |
| 2 levels for an unit (wargames) (6) by X3M |
| Board Game Blueprint - New Episode Every Wednesday (17) by The Game Crafter |
| Dragon Spark Playthrough (0) by The Game Crafter |
| New Board Game Pieces - Premium Water Droplet & Premium Blood Droplet (0) by The Game Crafter |
| Designer with an 'almost' ready product (18) by questccg |
| Protospiel Madison - Only 17 Days Away! (0) by The Game Crafter |
| New Board Game Pieces - Premium Milk Bottle & Premium Beer Mug (0) by The Game Crafter |
| Testing chat GPT for mechanics searching (6) by larienna |
| Build your own [insert game genre here] (0) by larienna |
| Epic Metal Monster Coins - Coming soon to Kickstarter - Need your feedback! (2) by questccg |
| Version 1.28 of nanDECK is available for download (0) by nand |
| I bought a reMarkable 2 as my 50th B-Day Gift (4) by questccg |
| How do you know if a game idea/project is obsolete? (5) by larienna |
| TGC Testimonial at 2D Con 2024 (0) by The Game Crafter |
| Pam Walls unboxes mystery box from The Game Crafter! (0) by The Game Crafter |
| What are "Factions"??? Are they UNITS per Faction or something else??? (24) by X3M |
This was a great way to answer the challenge, and a very natural evolution for Ludo.
(+) The evolution from Ludo into a pickup and deliver game is very natural. The mechanics are smooth and flow naturally from movement around the board. This could be a great starter version of a pickup and deliver game. The ability to ram other engines and so derail (heh heh) a shipment is a great addition.
(-) I'm not sure it really meets the second requirement of the challenge. Players have a hand of cards and manipulate cubes, but the game involves neither hand nor resource management. Keeping the waybills secret seems like an arbitrary complication that really doesn't add any tension to the game over having them be public knowledge.
(=) I'd definitely try to teach this to new or young gamers. The combination of waybills and movement options adds enough complexity to intrigue me without going full-on "Ticket to Ride".